[{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"source_summary","mode":"ar","completion":"no_finished_answer","quality":null,"tokens":12170,"seconds":475.22750758286566,"tps":25.709,"words":null,"review":{"id":"Answer-001","task":"source_summary","content_sha256":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":null,"completion":"no_finished_answer","dimension_scores":null,"total_quality_score":null,"strengths":[],"weaknesses":["No reviewable final answer."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"source_summary","mode":"mtp","completion":"finished_answer","quality":90,"tokens":13659,"seconds":378.15971962502226,"tps":36.444,"words":269,"review":{"id":"Answer-002","task":"source_summary","content_sha256":"b8e1625e33eeaf5f333bd29f9354cb535fe8a0d1b3f923caa6748ad307e0f73e","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":false,"completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_faithfulness":5,"decision_relevant_coverage":5,"clarity_organization":4,"natural_prose":3,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":90,"strengths":["Accurately distinguishes five percentage points from the10% reduction in missed count; preserves cost and approval uncertainty."],"weaknesses":["Opening recounts background before decision-relevant findings; prose is competent but report-like and densely enumerative."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"knowledge_explainer","mode":"ar","completion":"no_finished_answer","quality":null,"tokens":532,"seconds":32.02059624996036,"tps":17.526,"words":null,"review":{"id":"Answer-003","task":"knowledge_explainer","content_sha256":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":null,"completion":"no_finished_answer","dimension_scores":null,"total_quality_score":null,"strengths":[],"weaknesses":["No reviewable final answer."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"editorial_rewrite","mode":"mtp","completion":"finished_answer","quality":83,"tokens":7039,"seconds":165.94773245905526,"tps":42.704,"words":204,"review":{"id":"Answer-004","task":"editorial_rewrite","content_sha256":"1e248f20588548ddf6dc8cb0e4a5dbd18c1d796eca41430dcf02407baf9cf325","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":false,"completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_preservation":5,"reader_usefulness":4,"tone_natural_prose":3,"organization_concision":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":83,"strengths":["Preserves optional status, unconfirmed date, timing limitation, pricing uncertainty and no action today."],"weaknesses":["Repeats optional/current-search distinctions and retains internal phrasing such as \"QA has not signed off\"; considerate but somewhat mechanical."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"editorial_rewrite","mode":"ar","completion":"finished_answer","quality":83,"tokens":11560,"seconds":414.56032525002956,"tps":27.949,"words":196,"review":{"id":"Answer-005","task":"editorial_rewrite","content_sha256":"61da8efa89a9915547f36ef0287d6bb0a2770156f65e8e7c272ec6eb176ea3cc","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":false,"completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_preservation":5,"reader_usefulness":4,"tone_natural_prose":3,"organization_concision":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":83,"strengths":["Accurate, usable email with clear opt-in and timing qualifications."],"weaknesses":["\"This is not a main product launch\" feels like internal briefing text; repetitive qualification makes the voice stiff."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"data_to_report","mode":"mtp","completion":"finished_answer","quality":92,"tokens":5024,"seconds":126.83564091683365,"tps":40.403,"words":253,"review":{"id":"Answer-006","task":"data_to_report","content_sha256":"04b8772d1be4ad82c3b8e4fb4c77000fdfd712199e7919e3ec71e7c72cf9e5a4","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":false,"completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"numerical_accuracy":5,"interpretation_causal_caution":5,"decision_usefulness":4,"clarity_natural_prose":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":92,"strengths":["All six rates and their supporting fractions are correct; identifies composition shift and avoids attributing causation."],"weaknesses":["The cannot-conclude list spends words on several unavailable metrics; a tighter memo could foreground the proposed randomized comparison."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"data_to_report","mode":"ar","completion":"finished_answer","quality":76,"tokens":8005,"seconds":298.2055158750154,"tps":27.019,"words":266,"review":{"id":"Answer-007","task":"data_to_report","content_sha256":"1232933e3bba56b3573b657c609a243c230c5c28f001dfb6a59c0690154ee6f7","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":false,"completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"numerical_accuracy":3,"interpretation_causal_caution":4,"decision_usefulness":4,"clarity_natural_prose":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":76,"strengths":["Correct overall/device percentages, traffic-mix explanation and explicit warning against causal attribution."],"weaknesses":["Must correct the erroneous supporting fraction before use. Source-matched before/after comparison is weaker than randomization and still vulnerable to time confounding."],"factual_errors":[{"severity":"moderate","quote":"Mobile 10% (9,000/9,000)","explanation":"Period A mobile orders are900, not9000.900/9000 is10%;9000/9000 is100%. Main stated percentage and direction are correct, but the numerical evidence is not."}]}},{"cohort":"earlier requested-medium, actual-xhigh","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","task":"knowledge_explainer","mode":"mtp","completion":"no_finished_answer","quality":null,"tokens":621,"seconds":22.40654950006865,"tps":28.517,"words":null,"review":{"id":"Answer-008","task":"knowledge_explainer","content_sha256":"a7f25c01e9a2f703c946cc69929d31752baa9a8263789ade51fc0d356fa0fde5","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","major_factual_error":null,"completion":"no_finished_answer","dimension_scores":null,"total_quality_score":null,"strengths":[],"weaknesses":["Content is task planning and repetitive reasoning, not the requested finished article. Starts \"We need answer user's request\" and loops on the meaning of warmer."],"factual_errors":[]}},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-001","task":"data_to_report","content_sha256":"337206f3780bd006ad321ba534330f6315176ab0709de2e7e7e9f365ce2c4580","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"numerical_accuracy":5,"interpretation_causal_caution":5,"decision_usefulness":4,"clarity_natural_prose":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":92.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":232,"strengths":["Correct aggregate/device percentages, composition explanation and explicit causal caution."],"weaknesses":["Repeated cannot-conclude framing is wordy; controlled testing recommendation could be more specific about randomization."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"medium","mode":"ar","seconds":349.1557029581163,"tokens":10449,"tps":29.994},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-002","task":"data_to_report","content_sha256":"17421ec8c0d8b368ad2cd0acb6f209b11bdbfd46ec4196ac99fbb51c0cece034","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"numerical_accuracy":5,"interpretation_causal_caution":5,"decision_usefulness":4,"clarity_natural_prose":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":92.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":243,"strengths":["Correct aggregate/device percentages, composition explanation and explicit causal caution."],"weaknesses":["Repeated cannot-conclude framing is wordy; controlled testing recommendation could be more specific about randomization."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"medium","mode":"mtp","seconds":79.77331675007008,"tokens":3896,"tps":49.274},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-003","task":"source_summary","content_sha256":"9ed6c2647d65f4f3234e942d900369c2f9b96f03a0130e26e4d4697ab5f51e72","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_faithfulness":5,"decision_relevant_coverage":5,"clarity_organization":4,"natural_prose":3,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":90.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":272,"strengths":["Preserves rate/count distinction, causal uncertainty, costs, evidence limits and unapproved follow-up."],"weaknesses":["Dense, report-like narration; opens with background rather than the decision."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"medium","mode":"mtp","seconds":170.77482149982825,"tokens":9058,"tps":53.472},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-004","task":"knowledge_explainer","content_sha256":"a7f25c01e9a2f703c946cc69929d31752baa9a8263789ade51fc0d356fa0fde5","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"no_finished_answer","dimension_scores":null,"total_quality_score":null,"major_factual_error":null,"word_count_whitespace":388,"strengths":[],"weaknesses":["Task planning and repetitive reasoning, not a finished article."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"mtp","seconds":16.734902375144884,"tokens":621,"tps":38.103},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-005","task":"editorial_rewrite","content_sha256":"61da8efa89a9915547f36ef0287d6bb0a2770156f65e8e7c272ec6eb176ea3cc","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_preservation":5,"reader_usefulness":4,"tone_natural_prose":3,"organization_concision":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":83.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":196,"strengths":["Preserves optional status, unconfirmed date, test limitations, document delay, pricing uncertainty and no action today."],"weaknesses":["Some internal jargon and repetitive qualifications remain."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"ar","seconds":385.74305566609837,"tokens":11560,"tps":30.04},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-006","task":"source_summary","content_sha256":"b8e1625e33eeaf5f333bd29f9354cb535fe8a0d1b3f923caa6748ad307e0f73e","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_faithfulness":5,"decision_relevant_coverage":5,"clarity_organization":4,"natural_prose":3,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":90.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":265,"strengths":["Preserves rate/count distinction, causal uncertainty, costs, evidence limits and unapproved follow-up."],"weaknesses":["Dense, report-like narration; opens with background rather than the decision."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"mtp","seconds":317.4115030001849,"tokens":13659,"tps":43.223},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-007","task":"knowledge_explainer","content_sha256":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"no_finished_answer","dimension_scores":null,"total_quality_score":null,"major_factual_error":null,"word_count_whitespace":0,"strengths":[],"weaknesses":["No reviewable final answer."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"ar","seconds":24.610938166966662,"tokens":532,"tps":22.084},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-008","task":"data_to_report","content_sha256":"1232933e3bba56b3573b657c609a243c230c5c28f001dfb6a59c0690154ee6f7","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"numerical_accuracy":3,"interpretation_causal_caution":4,"decision_usefulness":4,"clarity_natural_prose":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":76.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":247,"strengths":["Correct aggregate/device percentages, composition explanation and explicit causal caution."],"weaknesses":["Correct the supporting mobile fraction before use. Source-matched before/after data remain vulnerable to time confounding."],"factual_errors":[{"severity":"moderate","quote":"Mobile 10% (9,000/9,000)","explanation":"The source has900 mobile orders/9000 visits. Stated10% is correct, but9000/9000 equals100%."}],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"ar","seconds":266.3440238330513,"tokens":8005,"tps":30.166},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-009","task":"editorial_rewrite","content_sha256":"53510a20a97a1c7f0667a9e5dcbfff4dff76ccf13b27c810680998b4bce51141","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_preservation":5,"reader_usefulness":4,"tone_natural_prose":3,"organization_concision":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":83.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":201,"strengths":["Preserves optional status, unconfirmed date, test limitations, document delay, pricing uncertainty and no action today."],"weaknesses":["Some internal jargon and repetitive qualifications remain."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"medium","mode":"mtp","seconds":199.1216273328755,"tokens":8724,"tps":44.068},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-010","task":"knowledge_explainer","content_sha256":"36b772f739a5973e5cd750f7be1a7e3e10a7585b4ba1a0cd8ad85901a8309ee6","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_accuracy":1,"clarity_explanation":2,"organization_flow":3,"concrete_useful_detail":1,"natural_voice":2,"brief_compliance":4},"total_quality_score":36.0,"major_factual_error":true,"word_count_whitespace":585,"strengths":["Has a title and connected prose within the requested length."],"weaknesses":["Polished form conceals a materially incomplete and misleading causal account; cannot recommend as a factual explainer.","Omits effective core interventions such as shade/vegetation and reflective surfaces; focuses excessively on lighting."],"factual_errors":[{"severity":"major","quote":"The core reason is straightforward: cities concentrate heat sources.","explanation":"The subsequent explanation wrongly centers lighting and continuing infrastructure heat. The expected account includes daytime solar heat stored in urban materials and released after sunset, reduced vegetative cooling, and urban geometry; waste heat is a contributor."},{"severity":"minor","quote":"a degree or two","explanation":"Presents a numerical temperature gap without local conditions or evidence despite the instruction against invented precise statistics."}],"effort":"medium","mode":"mtp","seconds":55.19579845806584,"tokens":1933,"tps":35.348},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-011","task":"data_to_report","content_sha256":"04b8772d1be4ad82c3b8e4fb4c77000fdfd712199e7919e3ec71e7c72cf9e5a4","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"numerical_accuracy":5,"interpretation_causal_caution":5,"decision_usefulness":4,"clarity_natural_prose":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":92.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":238,"strengths":["Correct aggregate/device percentages, composition explanation and explicit causal caution."],"weaknesses":["Repeated cannot-conclude framing is wordy; controlled testing recommendation could be more specific about randomization."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"mtp","seconds":110.14858275000006,"tokens":5024,"tps":46.02},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-012","task":"source_summary","content_sha256":"e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"no_finished_answer","dimension_scores":null,"total_quality_score":null,"major_factual_error":null,"word_count_whitespace":0,"strengths":[],"weaknesses":["No reviewable final answer."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"ar","seconds":412.2689237911254,"tokens":12170,"tps":29.628},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-013","task":"editorial_rewrite","content_sha256":"1842730b25b4ac3f2551f837b738eb93105746783249bec814f312ce2e3435a8","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_preservation":5,"reader_usefulness":4,"tone_natural_prose":4,"organization_concision":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":88.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":185,"strengths":["Preserves optional status, unconfirmed date, test limitations, document delay, pricing uncertainty and no action today."],"weaknesses":["More concise opening; still retains internal QA phrasing and a somewhat mechanical factual sequence."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"medium","mode":"ar","seconds":246.87364725000225,"tokens":7259,"tps":29.516},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-014","task":"editorial_rewrite","content_sha256":"1e248f20588548ddf6dc8cb0e4a5dbd18c1d796eca41430dcf02407baf9cf325","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_preservation":5,"reader_usefulness":4,"tone_natural_prose":3,"organization_concision":4,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":83.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":204,"strengths":["Preserves optional status, unconfirmed date, test limitations, document delay, pricing uncertainty and no action today."],"weaknesses":["Some internal jargon and repetitive qualifications remain."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"xhigh","mode":"mtp","seconds":150.13842045911588,"tokens":7039,"tps":47.151},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-015","task":"source_summary","content_sha256":"5e9cc4358686238669914f740fb02781b4aea5f260e6e08e2fddaf8ef43fb09c","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_faithfulness":5,"decision_relevant_coverage":5,"clarity_organization":4,"natural_prose":3,"brief_compliance":5},"total_quality_score":90.0,"major_factual_error":false,"word_count_whitespace":263,"strengths":["Preserves rate/count distinction, causal uncertainty, costs, evidence limits and unapproved follow-up."],"weaknesses":["Dense, report-like narration; opens with background rather than the decision."],"factual_errors":[],"effort":"medium","mode":"ar","seconds":125.76685825013556,"tokens":3742,"tps":30.164},{"cohort":"controlled medium/xhigh effort","model":"Original REAP-288 Q4g64, not custom","id":"Answer-016","task":"knowledge_explainer","content_sha256":"d23dbfb693432580668d0a1efca0d2acfacff8130e24c350c8770043418d1b06","reviewer":"Codex assistant rubric review","review_status":"reviewed","completion":"finished_answer","dimension_scores":{"factual_accuracy":1,"clarity_explanation":1,"organization_flow":3,"concrete_useful_detail":1,"natural_voice":2,"brief_compliance":4},"total_quality_score":31.0,"major_factual_error":true,"word_count_whitespace":518,"strengths":["Has a title and connected prose within the requested length."],"weaknesses":["Polished form conceals a materially incomplete and misleading causal account; cannot recommend as a factual explainer.","Omits effective core interventions such as shade/vegetation and reflective surfaces; focuses excessively on lighting."],"factual_errors":[{"severity":"major","quote":"Urban areas, however, keep their artificial lighting and infrastructure running through the night, so the local temperature plateaus at a higher level instead of drifting downward.","explanation":"The subsequent explanation wrongly centers lighting and continuing infrastructure heat. The expected account includes daytime solar heat stored in urban materials and released after sunset, reduced vegetative cooling, and urban geometry; waste heat is a contributor."},{"severity":"major","quote":"warm-white or neutral-white bulbs rather than the harsher amber tones that cast more thermal energy into the surrounding air","explanation":"Visible color temperature does not establish total fixture heat output; this cooling recommendation is unsupported."},{"severity":"moderate","quote":"It has nothing to do with the broad warming trends people discuss in climate-change headlines.","explanation":"Distinct mechanisms do not imply no relationship: local heat mitigation also supports resilience to climate change."},{"severity":"minor","quote":"a degree or two","explanation":"Presents a numerical temperature gap without local conditions or evidence despite the instruction against invented precise statistics."}],"effort":"medium","mode":"ar","seconds":45.0878898340743,"tokens":1397,"tps":31.294}]